You Can Only Teach What You Are: Why We Must Heal Before We Help

Subscribe

We've all done it: given advice we don't follow. Taught principles we haven't integrated. Helped others while avoiding our own healing work. We say the right things, perform the right behaviors, adopt the proper language—while internally operating from a completely different place.

This is what "fake it till you make it" really means: performing a version of wisdom we haven't genuinely embodied. And the cost isn't just personal—it's relational. When we teach before we've learned, when we help before we've healed, we inevitably pass on our unhealed patterns, no matter how sophisticated our language or well-intentioned our efforts.

We Teach From Where We Are, Not What We Know

There's a critical distinction between intellectual understanding and embodied knowing. We can read every book, memorize every framework, understand every principle—and still operate from our wounds.

What actually transmits from person to person isn't the content of our words but the quality of our being. We teach from where we are, not from where we think we should be or wish we were.

If we haven't genuinely worked through our anxiety, we'll teach anxious coping mechanisms even while talking about peace. If we haven't healed our relationship with control, we'll pass on controlling patterns even while preaching trust. If we haven't addressed our own shame, we'll subtly shame others even while speaking about self-compassion.

This creates a double lesson: the explicit lesson of our words, and the implicit lesson of our unhealed state. The explicit lesson says "you can heal," while the implicit lesson whispers "but I haven't, so maybe you can't either." People—especially children and those seeking guidance—pick up on this inconsistency, even when they can't articulate it.

The Helper Who Hasn't Healed

Many of us rush to help others as a way of avoiding our own healing work. We become the perpetual advice-giver, the fixer, the one everyone comes to—not because we've done deep work, but because focusing on others' problems is easier than facing our own.

The unexamined motivation often is: "If I can fix you, maybe I won't have to fix myself."

The pattern looks like this: jumping into helper roles before doing substantial personal work, giving advice we don't follow, feeling more comfortable addressing others' issues than our own, using our "helping" as evidence of our healing, becoming defensive when our unhealed patterns are pointed out, and burning out because we're operating from depletion rather than overflow.

The Perpetuation Cycle

When we teach what we haven't healed, we create learners who absorb our unhealed patterns alongside the healing principles we're trying to convey.

The parent who teaches their child to "use your words" while regularly yelling creates a child who intellectually knows communication matters but emotionally learns that volume equals power.

The teacher who preaches self-compassion while visibly berating themselves creates students who learn that self-compassion is an ideal to aspire to, not a lived reality.

This isn't just ineffective—it's harmful. The learner now carries both the original unhealthy pattern and the cognitive dissonance of believing one thing while doing another. They've learned to mistrust their perception because they see the gap between what's being taught and what's being demonstrated.

The Weakness of Inauthenticity

When we teach before we've genuinely learned, we weaken ourselves. There's a cost to maintaining the performance of wisdom we don't possess. It requires constant vigilance to maintain the gap between what we project and what we actually are.

We become exhausted from holding up the facade. We become defensive because criticism threatens to expose the gap. We become rigid because flexibility might reveal our uncertainty. The performance itself becomes the obstacle to real growth.

What Authentic Teaching Looks Like

Authentic teaching—whether as a professional or simply moving through relationships—comes from overflow, not depletion. It comes from sharing what we've genuinely learned, not performing what we think we should have learned.

Teach from our genuine edge, not beyond it. Share what we're actively integrating, not what we read last week. There's a vast difference between "I've been practicing this for years" and "I just learned this concept and I'm going to teach it to you."

Be honest about where we're still struggling. "I'm still learning how to do this" is often more helpful than "here's how you do this" when we're demonstrably still figuring it out ourselves.

Do our own work consistently. This means therapy, supervision, mentorship, reflection, feedback—whatever it takes to keep working through our own material. The work never ends, but there's a difference between someone actively engaged in their process and someone avoiding it while helping others.

Recognize when we're not the right teacher. Sometimes the most helpful thing we can do is acknowledge our limitations and point someone toward a better resource.

Create space for others to exceed us. When we're teaching from genuine integration, we can celebrate when others surpass us. When we're teaching from unhealed wounding, we feel threatened by their growth because it exposes our stagnation.

The Patient Path

The world needs helpers, teachers, and guides. But it doesn't need more people performing wisdom they don't possess. It needs us willing to do the slow, unglamorous work of healing ourselves first—or at least simultaneously.

This doesn't mean waiting until we're perfect. That's impossible. But it does mean being honest about where we are in our journey. It means teaching what we've actually integrated, not what we've recently intellectualized.

The deepest teaching comes not from those claiming to have all the answers, but from those who've done enough work on themselves that they can sit with others in uncertainty without needing to fix, advise, or rescue.

If we're drawn to help others—and that's a beautiful impulse—we must ask ourselves honestly: Are we teaching what we've learned, or performing what we think we should know? Are we overflowing from our own healing, or helping others to avoid doing our own work?

The answers matter. Because what we haven't healed in ourselves, we cannot truly heal in others. What we haven't genuinely learned, we cannot authentically teach. The world has enough mixed messages. What it needs now are people willing to be honest about their own journey while walking alongside others in theirs.

Subscribe