From Screen Time to Heart Time: Finding Balance in Teaching Emotional Intelligence

Subscribe

My 16-month-old is having a complete meltdown because I literally gave him what he wanted, only to find he doesn't like it now, and is mad that I gave it to him. I'm exhausted, running on five hours of broken sleep, and my phone is right there—one swipe away from home videos, Franklin, or Little Bear that would offer a few moments of peace for mama. Some days I resist. Some days I don't. And I'm learning that both responses can be okay.

This is the reality of parenting in 2025: every day, I'm making micro-decisions that will shape my child's emotional intelligence. Even with a degree in early childhood education and psychology, I'm figuring a lot out as I go—because nothing can prepare you for being a parent.

I went into parenting with strong convictions about avoiding any screen time before age 3. But parenting has a way of humbling even the most well-researched plans. I've learned that balance—not perfection—might be the key to both my sanity and my son's healthy development.

The Daily Struggle Is Real

Let me be honest: my toddler has massive amounts of energy that never seems to run out. He only sits still for more than 5-10 seconds unless he is sick or sleeping, and I find myself looking at the clock waiting for relief at the end of every day. It's chaos.

When I do use screens—maybe 15 minutes of Franklin or Little Bear, or more often, home videos of our family that he absolutely loves—it's strategic and intentional. Not as a daily babysitter or reward system, but as a tool when I truly need it: when he refuses to sit in his car seat and nothing else works, during our solo trip to Colorado to see family, or when I'm genuinely sick and need a small break.

Research shows that excessive screen use can lead to emotional issues such as anxiety, depression, and isolation. But here's what I've learned to ask myself: when he gets frustrated, does he usually have practice sitting with that frustration and trying again? The answer is yes.

What Heart Time Actually Looks Like

Heart time isn't some perfect Pinterest moment—it's choosing connection over convenience most of the time, while being honest about when you need help. It's messy, exhausting, and often inconvenient. But it's also where emotional intelligence develops.

During the grocery store meltdown: Instead of immediately handing over my phone, I kneel down and acknowledge his feelings. "You're really upset. This is hard." I don't fix it or distract from it—I just stay present. But if we're having a particularly rough day and I pull out a home video of grandma singing to him? I'm learning not to guilt myself about that choice.

When he's bored and fussy: Most of the time, I let him experience the discomfort of having nothing stimulating to do. These moments teach him to tap into his own resources. But sometimes, when I'm at my limit, those gentle '90s cartoons buy me enough peace to reset so I can be present for him again.

During car rides: We usually rely on snacks, books, and conversation instead of screens. But on a day when he refuses to settle and it turns into hysterical crying and hyperventilation, Franklin the Turtle becomes my co-pilot—and that's the right choice for both of us.

During meals: Phones away, always. Mealtime remains consistently screen-free in our house.

The Science That Guides (Not Guilts) Me

Genuine human connection activates the social brain networks responsible for empathy, emotional regulation, and relationship skills. Screens can activate reward pathways that compete with these processes, but the keyword is "can"—not "will" or "always."

My son's emotional intelligence develops through how I handle my own emotions and connect with him. That includes recognizing when I need support to be my best self—even if that support sometimes comes in the form of 15 minutes of screen time while I catch my breath.

What Actually Works

Create Device-Free Zones: Bedrooms, high chair, and most car rides are screen-free. It's not always peaceful, but it's where connection usually happens.

Model Emotional Awareness: When I'm frustrated, I narrate instead of hide. "Mama is feeling overwhelmed right now." He's watching everything—including how I handle my own limits.

Be Intentional, Not Perfect: When I do use screens, it's purposeful. Home videos that connect him with family, or gentle shows during genuinely challenging moments—not as a default routine.

Remember the Long Game: Children with high emotional intelligence become adults who can handle stress and make decisions from self-awareness rather than reactivity. This develops through consistent presence—not perfect presence.

The Truth About This Journey

Every day, I face hundreds of moments where I can choose convenience or connection. Am I perfect at this? Absolutely not. But I'm learning that maintaining my mental health and ability to be present requires occasional breaks—and sometimes those breaks involve screens.

The goal isn't zero screen time; it's intentional screen time that doesn't replace genuine connection but occasionally supports it by helping me reset.

My pre-parenting ideals about zero screen time were perhaps too rigid for the reality of raising a spirited toddler while maintaining my own emotional health. The home videos of him giggling with grandparents aren't undermining his development—they're connecting him to love and joy.

I'm still figuring this out, one meltdown at a time. The moments when I choose connection over convenience most of the time, when I stay present in his big feelings instead of always distracting from them—those are the moments his emotional intelligence is developing.

To the parents using no screens at all: you're amazing. To the parents finding balance with intentional, limited screen use: you're not failing your children. To the parents who use screens more than they'd like: you're still good parents doing your best.

We're all just trying to raise emotionally intelligent humans in a complicated world. And sometimes, that means being gentle with ourselves too.

Subscribe